7. Pick ‘n Save
Reader Score: 71 out of 100
Year founded: 1872
Locations: Wisconsin
What you need to know: Don’t shop here for organic options, that much is clear. The chain — operated by Roundy’s Supermarkets — pulled a “poor” score in that key area. And readers ranked it only “fair” in the competitive pricing, checkout speed, produce quality, and local produce quantity categories.